In an investigation to study the effect of smoking on renal cell carcinoma, it is observed that 30 out of 50 patients were smokers as compared to 10 out of 50 control subjects. The odd ratio of renal cell carcinoma associated with smoking will be
First, I need to recall what an odds ratio (OR) is. The OR is a measure of association between an exposure (smoking) and an outcome (renal cell carcinoma). It's calculated as (a/d)/(b/c), where a is the number of cases with the exposure, b is the number of controls with the exposure, c is the number of cases without the exposure, and d is the number of controls without the exposure.
Looking at the data provided: 30 out of 50 patients (cases) are smokers, so a=30. The remaining 20 cases are non-smokers, so c=20. For controls, 10 out of 50 are smokers (b=10), and 40 are non-smokers (d=40).
Plugging into the formula: OR = (30/20)/(10/40) = (1.5)/(0.25) = 6. So the OR should be 6.
Now, checking the answer options. The correct answer is probably option C if the options are in order. But since the options aren't provided, I need to structure the explanation clearly.
The core concept here is understanding how to calculate the odds ratio in a case-control study. The key is arranging the data correctly into a 2x2 contingency table.
The correct answer is right because the calculation follows the standard formula. The incorrect options might result from miscalculations, like using risk ratio instead of odds ratio, or mixing up the numerator and denominator.
Clinical pearl: Remember that odds ratio is used in case-control studies, while relative risk is used in cohort studies. For rare diseases, OR approximates RR, but when the disease is common, they diverge significantly.
Make sure to present each section clearly, explain why each wrong option is incorrect, and highlight the key takeaway.
**Core Concept**
The question assesses the calculation of an **odds ratio (OR)** in a **case-control study** to determine the association between smoking (exposure) and renal cell carcinoma (outcome). The OR quantifies the odds of exposure in cases versus controls, calculated as (a/c)/(b/d), where a=exposed cases, b=exposed controls, c=unexposed cases, d=unexposed controls.
**Why the Correct Answer is Right**
Given:
- Cases (patients with RCC): 30 smokers (a), 20 non-smokers (c).
- Controls: 10 smokers (b), 40 non-smokers (d).
OR = (a/c)/(b/d) = (30/20)/(10/40) = (1.5)/(0.25) = **6**.
This indicates **smokers have 6x higher odds of RCC** compared to non-smokers. The OR is appropriate here because case-control studies cannot calculate relative risk directly.
**Why Each Wrong Option is Incorrect**
**Option A:** Likely assumes a **risk ratio (RR)** instead of OR. RR = (a/(a+c))/(b/(b+d)) = (30