Which of the following murmur increases on standing?
First, I remember that certain cardiac murmurs change with body position. For example, in hypertrophic obstructive cardiomyopathy (HOCM), the murmur of systolic ejection becomes louder when the patient stands up. This is because standing causes venous return to decrease, reducing left ventricular volume. In HOCM, the outflow obstruction is more pronounced with lower filling volumes, so the murmur intensifies.
Other possibilities include mitral valve prolapse, where murmurs might change with position, but I think the key here is the mechanism related to preload. When standing, there's a decrease in venous return (preload), which affects conditions that are preload-dependent.
Aortic stenosis murmur is typically unaffected by position. Mitral regurgitation might not have a significant positional change. So the correct answer is likely HOCM. The other options would be incorrect because their murmurs don't respond the same way to positional changes.
The clinical pearl here is that HOCM's murmur increases with standing and decreases with squatting, which is a key exam point. So the correct answer should be the option corresponding to HOCM.
**Core Concept**
Positional changes like standing alter venous return, affecting preload and cardiac murmurs. In **hypertrophic obstructive cardiomyopathy (HOCM)**, decreased preload from standing intensifies the systolic ejection murmur due to worsened outflow tract obstruction.
**Why the Correct Answer is Right**
In HOCM, the left ventricular outflow tract obstruction is dynamic and preload-dependent. Standing reduces venous return (preload), leading to smaller left ventricular volume. This increases the gradient across the stenotic outflow tract, amplifying the murmur. The mechanism involves **asymmetric septal hypertrophy** and **systolic anterior motion of the mitral valve**.
**Why Each Wrong Option is Incorrect**
**Option A:** Aortic stenosis murmur remains unchanged with position; it’s determined by valve calcification, not preload.
**Option B:** Mitral regurgitation murmur (holosystolic) is unaffected by standing; severity depends on regurgitant volume.
**Option C:** Mitral valve prolapse murmurs may change with respiration (e.g., worse on inspiration) but not significantly with standing.
**Clinical Pearl / High-Yield Fact**
HOCM murmur becomes **louder on standing** and **quieter on squatting** (due to increased preload during squatting). This is a classic exam trap—confusion with aortic stenosis can occur if positional changes are not assessed.
**Correct Answer: C. Hypertrophic obstructive cardiomyopathy**